Best Mattresses in a Box 2020

Having trouble sleeping at night? It's important to choose a mattress that provides
you with maximum comfort and support. Compare the best mattresses in a box and
find the one that best suits your sleeping habits.

UPDATED FOR JANUARY 2020
Logo
Score
Top Features
Price (USD)
9.9

  • Comfortable & versatile construction
  • Effective motion isolation
  • 100-night risk free trial
  • $985
    $1,095
    Queen

The Good / Casper mattress provides an ideal option if you are mainly looking for comfort with a touch of support and pressure relief. 

The Bad / The medium firmness of Casper Mattresses may be too soft for sleepers of a heavier weight due to the foam materials.

The Bottom Line / The Casper mattress offers a comfortable feel with a supportive base making it an adequate option for petite to average weight sleepers. 

thetop10sites.com image
9.6

  • Unique cooling cloud foam
  • Adapts to all sleepers
  • 101-night trial
  • $850
    $1150
    Queen

The Good / Puffy provides affordable memory foam mattresses with free shipping. Mattresses suit all sleep positions and provide temperature stabilization for weather throughout the year. 

The Bad / Puffy sells its products exclusively online so you won’t be able to lay on the mattress in person before purchasing. Also, Puffy isn’t ideal for heavy weight sleepers. 

The Bottom Line / Based in the United States, Puffy produces comfortable memory foam mattresses ideal for all sleep positions that come with a 101 night sleep trial.

thetop10sites.com image
9.4

  • Most popular mattress-in-a-box
  • $100 Off + 2 Premium Pillows
  • 365-night risk-free home trial
  • Free shipping and returns
  • $699
    $799
    Queen

The Good / Nectar costs less than most foam mattresses. You can purchase a queen model for $699 including shipping, 365 trial period, and forever warranty. 

The Bad / If you’re looking for the sink-in, contouring feeling of memory foam, Nectar Sleep mattresses tend to feel firmer compared to other brands. 

The Bottom Line / Nectar consists of a dual layer memory foam with a cooling gel top layer. The mattress offers good back support and feels firmer than most foam models.

thetop10sites.com image
9.2

  • Best value mattress-in-a-box
  • 3 adjustable firmness options
  • ECO-Tex memory foam
  • Fast & free delivery
  • $530
    $730
    Queen

The Good / Ecosa mattresses give customers full flexibility. Customers can adjust mattress firmness at any time using three different removable layers. 

The Bad / Ecosa mattresses has limited online reviews from previous customers. Some complain of difficulty changing mattress layers as well as mattresses lacking any bounce. 

The Bottom Line / Engineered by NASA-funded researchers, Ecosa mattresses provide a state-of-the-art mattress with a 100 day trial and 15 year warranty. 

thetop10sites.com image
8.9

  • Premium foam construction
  • Made in the USA
  • Optimal support & pressure relief
  • Free delivery & returns
  • $849
    $999
    Queen

The Good / Available in 3 design choices, the Leesa mattress offers the perfect combination of support and quality.

The Bad / Customers can purchase their mattress online for delivery to their home. However, a new mattress may have a temporary odor.

The Bottom Line / Since 2014, the Leesa Mattress company has offered premium foam mattresses online and stands out as one of the original bed-in-a box companies. 

thetop10sites.com image
8.6

  • Hybrid foam and coil construction
  • Advanced cooling gel
  • Free Shipping
  • $788
    $985
    Queen

The Good / Allswell mattress provides an affordable, hybrid mattress that pleases all types of sleepers. It comes with extra features such as cooling properties to ensure you have a perfect night's sleep.  

The Bad / Allwell limits its warranty to one mattress per year for ten years only, whereas some mattress companies offer a generous lifetime warranty.  

The Bottom Line / Overall, the Allswell is exactly what the name suggests: a crowd pleaser mattress with all the necessary features and benefits to give you the best night's sleep possible. 

thetop10sites.com image

Joe Schwartz | Mattresses Editor

Our chief content editor, Joe manages a diverse team of content writers. He holds a degree in online communications and his writing has been featured in a wide range of online publications.

All You Need to Know About Mattresses in a Box

Looking to purchase a mattress in a box but unsure where to start? You've come to the right place! In addition to our comparison chart and in-depth mattress reviews, we've compiled a list of some of the most commonly asked questions about mattresses in a box.

 

What is a mattress in a box?

A mattress in a box, often a foam mattress comes compressed in a conveniently sized box before shipping. This way, it creates less hassle when shopping and is often more affordable.

Typically, when you open a mattress in a box it will quickly unfurl and start to grow in size once on the bedframe or floor. This is because the mattress has been packed so tightly into a box and requires time to expand. Most mattresses will only take a few minutes to fully expand but others may take a few hours or even days. It's best to consult the instructions that will come with your mattress in a box.

 

 

What are some signs that you need a new mattress?

Every case is unique and while some mattresses may last 10 years, others may be perfectly fine for even longer. Here are some of the most common signs it's time to swap out your mattress for something new:

  • You wake up with aches and pains as it no longer provides sufficient support.
  • You experience discomfort throughout the night which makes it harder to fall asleep.
  • The mattress is visibly sinking or sagging in the center.
  • You are sneezing or have heightened allergies due to trapped dust or dust mites within the mattress.

If any of the above applies to you, it's time to start looking for a new mattress. After all, a good night's sleep can make all the difference.

 

 

How can you prolong the lifespan of your mattress?

In order to keep your mattress in good shape, it is recommended for you to rotate your mattress once every 6-8 months. This is because your body can eventually leave an impression on the same spot so rotating allows it to recover and makes it less likely to wear out. Furthermore, a mattress protector can help prevent sweat from leaking through onto your mattress and ruining the mattress material.

 

 

What is the difference between a memory foam and innerspring mattress?

Memory foam mattresses are designed in order to conform to the shape of your body. The memory foam responds to your body heat and pressure. When you get off the mattress it will return back to its original shape. Innerspring mattresses are made up of spring coils which are surrounded by layers of padding, reducing overall motion transfer. in terms of deciding as to what is a better choice, it really is a matter of opinion and what sort of sleeper you are as well as the quality of the mattress.

 

 

What is the difference between a Euro Top and a Pillow Top?

A Euro Top is an extra layer of stitching  which offers plush support, they are useful for those with neck or back pain. A Pillow Top is an extra layer sewn to the top of the mattress in order to add an extra layer of softness.

 

 

How do you know which comfort level is best for you?

Mattresses typically range from being extra soft, soft, medium, medium firm to firm and extra firm. Choosing a firmness level usually depends on a few different factors which include body weight and sleep positions. Those who are lighter in weight usually find soft to medium mattresses more comfortable, as opposed to those with heavier builds that would typically go for a firmer mattress. Although very soft mattresses are not usually recommended softer ones are usually best for side sleepers as it allows it to conform to their body. Medium firm mattresses are probably the most popular as they contour pressure points without sinking, they are suitable for all sleeping positions.